The BBC ran this story this morning, concerning a class incident in Taiwan that was caught on film by a student using his cellphone video camera. In the clip, a young female Taiwanese teacher is seen to be smacking the palms of a boy with a wooden stick who, reportedly, handed his homework in ten days after the deadline. The boy was then made to turn around as the teacher smacked his arse in a similar fashion. I tried to find the clip so I could see this for myself, but you can imagine the results of a google search with a search-string of words like ‘caning’ ’school’ and ‘video’.
The whole thing seems to be causing quite a stir. Many feel this to be a primitive, retrograde act that should be outlawed as soon as possible, along with most other ‘developed’ nations.
“Corporal punishment has been a cultural practice in Taiwan. But we believe schools and homes are the most important environment for kids to grow up and we need to eliminate this practice,” said Guan Bi-ling, a legislator from the governing Democratic Progressive Party, who has introduced the amendment.
“Many countries worldwide have banned corporal punishment in schools by law – including China. We think Taiwan is an advanced country, and we shouldn’t trail behind”, she said.
But others insist that it is a necessary punative measure and even imply that parents not only tolerate, but activley encourage it.
“Some people say we should have considered the position of the teacher,” said Kim Wang, of the Humanistic Education Foundation, a non-governmental group which is pushing for a ban of corporal punishment in schools.
“Other parents said they favoured teachers using that kind of method to discipline their children.”
As for me, I am appalled and disgusted by this video clip. It sickens me to the pit of my stomach that this kind of blatant student espionage is allowed to happen in this day and age. The boy that filmed this event must be punished. His cellphone should be siezed and a ban on all similar devices in the classroom should be initiated and enforced as soon as possible. We cannot allow our students to film the practice of corporal punishment in schools in this manner. The teacher waited ten days for this boys homework. TEN days! If it had been me I would have done it after 2 hours. After all, Taiwan kids have it easy here right? Short school hours, no tests, no pressure, no out-of-school cramming in early-morning or late-evening bushibans, no homework, no obsessive parents who lock them in their bedrooms after 8pm and force them into an unwanted path of academic hellfire and brimstone.
We need to toughen-up these lazy slackers.









